List journal issues    
Home List journal issues Table of contents Subscribe to PAQ


Volume 27 • Number 2

April 2013


Fantasy, Conceivability, and Ticking Bombs

by Peter Brian Barry

During the debates about the "McCain Amendment" that would ban cruel, inhuman, or degrading treatment of any prisoner by any agent of the United States, commentator Charles Krauthammer invoked a ticking-bomb scenario in defense of the handful of United States senators who failed to support it: Let's take the textbook case. Ethics 101: A terrorist has planted a nuclear bomb in New York City. It will go off in one hour. A million people will die. You capture the terrorist. He knows where it is. He's not talking. Question: If you have the slightest belief that hanging this man by his thumbs will get you the information to save a million people, are you permitted to do it? Now, on most issues regarding torture, I confess tentativeness and uncertainty. But on this issue, there can be no uncertainty: Not only is it permissible to hang this miscreant by his thumbs. It is a moral duty. Note Krauthammer's conclusion: it is not merely morally permissible but obligatory to torture in these circumstances. No surprise that he concludes that "the McCain amendment…cannot be right" and "[t]here must be exceptions" to prohibitions of torture.

view PDF



Home | Issue Index
© 2013 by the Board of Trustees of the University of Illinois
Content in Public Affairs Quarterly is intended for personal, noncommercial use only. You may not reproduce, publish, distribute, transmit, participate in the transfer or sale of, modify, create derivative works from, display, or in any way exploit the Public Affairs Quarterly database in whole or in part without the written permission of the copyright holder.

ISSN: 2152-0542